Guide · AT-R21REV. 2026-A

Buying a printer: inkjet or laser?

The question is usually asked the wrong way. There are not two technologies but three, and the third is the reason the old rule of thumb no longer holds.

By Benjamin ReichertNetworks, hardware, support · IT specialist for system integration (Fachinformatiker, IHK)Last updated:

For years the advice was: if you print a lot, buy a laser. If you print rarely, buy a laser too, because ink dries up. That rule dates from the time when every inkjet printer used cartridges. Since tank systems arrived, it no longer holds as it stands.

Three types of printer

Cartridge printers. Cheap to buy, expensive to run. The nozzles often sit in the cartridge or directly in the device and dry out if nothing is printed for weeks. The worst choice for people who rarely print, and yet it is what stands at the front of the electronics shop.

Tank printers (EcoTank, MegaTank, Smart Tank and whatever else the manufacturers call them). More expensive to buy, much cheaper per page. They are refilled from bottles. These devices are built for long idle periods; that largely eases the drying-out problem, but does not remove it.

Laser printers. Toner is a powder, so it does not dry out: a device can stand for months and then print straight away. Text is razor-sharp and smudge-proof. Colour lasers are expensive, and the technology is not suited to photos.

ColourPhotostext onlyprint littleprint a lotTANKTANKLASERLASERCartridge: only for very low use and a tight budget

Which question really decides

Not “a lot or a little”, but: Do you need colour that has to look good?

If not, that is, invoices, forms, official paperwork and train tickets: then a laser. Whether you print ten or a thousand pages a month. The device sits unused for months and still works, and that is exactly the point.

If yes, that is, holiday photos, invitations and craft templates for the grandchildren: then a tank printer. Colour lasers cost more and give poorer results with photos.

The cartridge printer remains as a third option, if you really only need a few pages a year and do not want to invest anything. Then it is the right decision. Just be aware that it does not stay that way over the years.

What a page costs

The purchase price is the smaller part. What matters is what a page costs, and you can work that out yourself: the price of the cartridge or toner divided by the stated page yield.

The page yield figures are based on a standard test page with about five per cent coverage. That is not much. Your pages will be above that, often well above. As a rough guide across all three classes: cartridges expensive, tanks cheap, lasers for black and white between mid-range and cheap.

The printing cost calculator works with your own figures: enter two or three printers, add pages per month and the share of colour, and it shows the cost per page, the total cost and the month from which the more expensive printer pays off. What the device costs in electricity per year is worked out by the electricity cost calculator using the TEC value from the data sheet.

What else to look for when buying

Duplex, that is, double-sided printing. Saves paper and is no hassle. Costs hardly any extra, but is missing on entry-level devices.

Network, not just USB. You can print to a device on Wi-Fi from any computer or your phone. A USB printer is attached to one computer, and that computer has to be running.

No subscription lock-in. Some manufacturers tie cheap devices to an ink subscription. That can work out, but you need to know you are signing up to it, and that without a connection to the manufacturer the printer may do less.

Availability of consumables in a few years. With models from a widespread range this is no issue, with bargains from discontinued ranges it is.

If the new device is in place and will not print, the guide “Printer not printing” will help. With new devices the cause is almost always the network setup.

Common questions

Does ink really dry up if you rarely print?

With cartridge printers, yes, it is a real problem. With tank systems much less so: manufacturers designed the print heads for it, and the tank holds a larger reserve of ink. Even so, it cannot sit completely idle. One colour page a month is usually enough.

What does a page actually cost?

The manufacturer’s figure is based on a standardised test page with roughly five per cent coverage, meaning little text and no images. Your pages will usually be above that. Allow for roughly half the stated page yield and you will be closer to realistic figures.

Is an all-in-one worth it?

Almost always, because the extra cost for the scanner and copier is small, and a separate device takes up more space and needs a second driver. The drawback: if one part fails, usually the whole device is affected.

Are third-party cartridges a good idea?

They are legal and often much cheaper. Two things you should know: some devices stop recognising them after a firmware update, and if third-party material causes damage, the manufacturer may refuse the warranty. With a cheap printer that is tolerable, with an expensive one less so.

Why are some printers so cheap?

Because the money is made on consumables. A device for under seventy euros often comes with half-filled starter cartridges, and the first replacement costs more than the printer. The purchase price therefore says little about the total cost.

+49 3744 4399760Mon–Fri 8:00–17:00
CallCallback

PARTS LIST · SHEET 1/1

What this page is made of

Values measured at build time. With JavaScript, your browser measures them again live.

ITEMPARTTYPESIZE
01index.htmlDocument≈ 29 kB
02styles.cssStylesheet≈ 20 kB
03scripts.jsScript≈ 13 kB
04archivo-variable.woff2Font≈ 58 kB
05ibm-plex-mono.woff2Font≈ 30 kB
06favicon.svgImage< 1 kB

Advertising or analytics cookies: none. Without your consent, the page loads nothing from third-party servers apart from Cloudflare, our delivery service. Fonts, scripts and images are hosted by us. That is how we build your IT, too.

OUTSIDE OFFICE HOURS

Feel free to call anyway

Our regular office hours are Monday to Friday, 8:00–17:00.

In the evening and at weekends the number is forwarded to us, and often someone will pick up. We cannot promise that, though.

If nobody answers, leave a short message on the voicemail: your name, your number and what it is about. We will call back as soon as we can, on the next working day at the latest.

The call costs nothing. If someone has to start work straight away outside office hours, the surcharge in the price list applies.

Call now+49 3744 4399760

Prefer to write? Use the contact form or e-mail [email protected]. We will read it on the next working day.

DIAGNOSIS · AT-K2

What do you need help with?

↵ SELECTESC CLOSECALL: +49 3744 4399760

Custom settings

Which services may load?

Strictly necessary

The choice you make here and your settings for colour scheme and motion. These are kept as small entries on your device and are never sent to a server. They are needed for the site to work and therefore cannot be switched off.