Guide · AT-R11REV. 2026-A
Hard drive failed: what you should never do now

By Benjamin ReichertNetworks, hardware, support · IT specialist for system integration (Fachinformatiker, IHK)Last updated:
If you are reading this on your phone while the computer next to you is still running: switch it off. Hold down the power button. Do not shut it down normally.
You can read the rest afterwards.
Why switching off is so urgent
On a hard drive that is mechanically damaged, every further turn of the platter does more harm. The read/write head normally floats on a razor-thin cushion of air above the platter. If it touches the surface, it scrapes off the magnetic layer. And what has been scraped off cannot be brought back by anyone, not even a lab.
If the drive clicks, ticks, grinds or keeps spinning up again at intervals, that is not a software problem. It is mechanical. Switch it off immediately.
An SSD has no moving parts, but it has a different problem: the controller stays active as long as power is applied and keeps working in the background. That, too, can make things worse.
The five reactions that make it worse
- Carrying on working and hoping for the best. The most common mistake. It still runs, after all, more or less. Every minute it stays in use costs you data.
- Switching off and on again. And again. With a mechanical fault, every start attempt is another pass over the damaged area. After the fifth attempt there is usually less to recover than after the first.
- Running a recovery program on it. Never install such a tool on the affected drive, and never write the files it finds back to that drive. You would overwrite exactly what was still there. You would also keep the drive under load for hours while it is dying anyway. If the drive is making noises, no software will help at all.
- Letting Windows repair it. When Windows offers to check and repair the drive, it sounds well meant. But such checks write changes to the file system. On a faulty drive, that can destroy directory structures that were still intact.
- Opening it up. There is a tip going round to put the drive in the freezer or to open the casing and have a look. Please do not. Outside a clean room, an opened hard drive is contaminated with dust within seconds. A lab can still get such drives to work, but the chances drop considerably and the recovery becomes much more expensive.
What makes sense instead
Switch the device off and leave the drive in place. Leave everything else as it is.
Write down what happened. Did the computer fall? Was there a power cut? Does the drive make noises? Was anything deleted or formatted? These details decide how to proceed, and afterwards nobody remembers them exactly.
And then the most important question: how important is the data, really? Everything depends on that. For holiday photos, a lab rarely pays off. For the last ten years of your accounts, it is a different matter.
How professional recovery works
The first step is always the same: a complete copy of the drive is made, sector by sector, with a device that skips damaged areas instead of getting stuck on them.
From then on, work is done only on this copy. The original is not touched again. If a recovery attempt fails, a fresh working copy of the image is made and something else is tried.
That is exactly the difference from a program off the internet. Not cleverer software, but the fact that nobody keeps operating on the patient.
With mechanical damage, this can no longer be done at a desk. A lab can still replace a faulty circuit board with the casing closed. But as soon as heads, motor or platters have to be handled, the drive must go into a clean room. That is specialist lab work, takes days to weeks, and the cost is usually in the mid to high three-figure range, higher for serious damage. Reputable providers carry out an analysis first and give you a price afterwards. Anyone who guarantees success beforehand should make you suspicious.
An unpleasant paragraph to finish
Data recovery is no substitute for a backup. It is what is left when there was none.
It is expensive, it takes time, and it does not always work. A backup costs a fraction of that, and it gets you working again much faster.
Even a NAS with two mirrored drives is not yet a backup: a delete command or encryption ransomware hits both at the same time. How much space a RAID actually leaves, and how much storage a backup with versions needs, is worked out by the NAS and RAID calculator.
If you are reading this article in the middle of an emergency: deal with the drive first. But then set yourself an appointment. What a backup that holds up in an emergency should look like is covered in our guides to the 3-2-1 rule and the restore test.
And once the faulty drive has been replaced: do not just throw it away. The guide “Old PC to go: erasing data, disposing of it or reusing it” describes what has to happen to the data first. The data erasure assistant shows the way for your drive, including a faulty one.
There is one limit where we cannot do anything either: an encrypted drive whose recovery key nobody has any more. Where this key is kept and how to record it for an emergency is covered in “Digital legacy: what is lost without access details”.
Whether the drive is to blame at all can often be read from how the computer starts. How far a computer gets and what that says about the cause is shown in “PC will not start: what you can check and when to stop”.
If the drive is still running normally, the hard drive check can flag signs of a likely failure. Paste the text from CrystalDiskInfo to see the result.
The second failure is bound to come. It is just that nobody knows when.